The Gilmore-Rosenberg Debate:
Suffering, Morality, and the Existence of God
On Tuesday September 27th, 2016 two of the nation's leading academics engaged in a debate addressing the most fundamental question of human life: Does God exist? Mortimer Adler says in The Great Ideas (i.e. The Great Books) Syntopicon that more consequences for thought and action follow from affirming or denying God than from answering any other basic question. The late atheist Christopher Hitchens said, prior to his death, that the God question is the most powerful and urgent question confronted by humanity. At Mershon Auditorium on the campus of The Ohio State University, Freed-Hardeman professor of Bible and philosophy Ralph Gilmore dueled Duke University professor of philosophy Alexander Rosenberg on life's most important question. Does the presence of suffering in our world prove that God does not exist? Or might it in fact, prove that He does? In this debate both of these supremely qualified disputants affirm and deny the premise of the strongest argument concerning the subject. We invite you to ask the difficult questions, weigh the evidence, and follow the evidence where it leads.
“Sometimes we suffer because we are in a world that challenges us to meet God on the other side...”
Get the most out of your debate viewing with your very own copy of the transcript, featuring hi-res images from each slide, painstakingly reproduced and arranged for readability.
Print version of one night debate held September 27, 2016, on the campus of The Ohio State University between Dr. Ralph Gilmore, professor of Bible and Philosophy, Freed-Hardeman University, Henderson, TN, and Dr. Alexander Rosenberg, professor of Philosophy, Duke University, Durham, NC. The question of God has the potential to affect us in the most far reaching ways beyond any other question we might consider. The intellectual battle between Christian theism and atheism remains the most important duel in the world. If Professor Rosenberg is right about evolution and there being no infinite God, then nothing really matters. On the other hand, if Professor Gilmore is right, that man can know that God exists, then nothing else matters more.